"O, Say, can you see?" The highly recognizable first few words of our national anthem, written over 200 years ago, suddenly became a hot-button topic some time ago. The poem written by Francis Scott Key in 1814, later set to the melody of a British tavern drinking song, was inspired by a victorious battle fought by Americans against British forces at Fort McHenry during the War of 1812. The U.S. successfully defended the Fort and Old Glory was seen waving over the battlefield. Key, a lawyer and amateur poet, set the scene to verse in a four-stanza poem.
These are the high-entropy or disordered elements that comprised what would become "The Star-Spangled Banner", the song that was officially adopted as our national anthem in 1931. President Woodrow Wilson had recognized the song for official use in 1916, but an act of Congress tied the low-entropy knot between Americans and their "permanent" anthem on March 3, 1931. I use quote marks to frame the word "permanent" because today, nearly 100 years after the adoption of this exalted and inspirational paean to the Stars and the Stripes, it is now the flashpoint of controversy. Long held as the theme song for Americans at public gatherings such as sporting events and political conventions, its boastful first stanza lyric has received an immediate "stop-what-you're-doing" attention and respect for well over 100 years, even prior to its official sanctioning. But many people, to whom the symbolism that is reflected within the song's subsequent verses, namely within the third stanza, the awed reverence is not due--not to the nation's leadership, not to some members of law enforcement who represent local governments, not even to the symbolic representation of the flag itself. When a highly visible, uniformed, major league football player opted out of the usual posture of respect during the playing or singing of "The Star-Spangled Banner" before scores of thousands of fans present and millions of TV viewers, the acting out of a protest of this magnitude sparked renewed curiosity of the revered anthem. The third stanza, as it turns out, celebrated the Union's dominance and punitive retaliation over slaves who sought possible freedom (in the Land of the "Free") by siding with British forces during the War of 1812. The treasured anthem has been struck by high-entropy bombs bursting in air.
With an association that strikes raw nerves the way that the topic of slavery does here in America, the national anthem caused people to take sides on the issues of patriotism, racial inequality, and freedom of expression. An exercise that historically demonstrated love of country, symbolized by Key's homage to the Battle of Baltimore, even if performed in a perfunctory manner, resulted in stadium brawls and shouting matches from sea to shining sea. No more low-entropy acceptance for the anthem, at least not unless we (the human brain) decide to hold onto it in its present low-entropy state, drop the offending lyric, or do away with this anthem altogether. But at least for now, the singing goes on.
